Storm-Damage Roof Documentation After Matthew, Florence, and the Storms Since

Hurricane Matthew in 2016 and Hurricane Florence in 2018 both pushed the Cape Fear River out of its banks and dropped wind-driven rain on commercial roofs across Cumberland County that were nowhere near the coast. We've documented and repaired that kind of damage since, and every claim-support job runs on getting the paperwork right, not on a promised result.

What Tropical Systems Actually Do to a Roof Here

Fayetteville doesn't take a hurricane's eyewall. What it takes is the remnant band: sustained wind well below hurricane force but blowing for twelve or eighteen hours straight, plus rainfall totals that overwhelm drains and scuppers sized for a normal thunderstorm. Florence dropped more rain on parts of this region over several days than most roofs see in a season.

That combination causes a specific damage pattern: membrane lifted at the perimeter and at parapet walls before it fails in the field, ponding on roofs with marginal slope or clogged drains, and water intrusion at penetrations that held fine under normal rain but not under a sustained saturated load.

River flooding is the other half of it. Buildings near the Cape Fear River corridor and in low-lying parts of Cumberland and Robeson counties saw water damage from below as well as above during both storms, which complicates a claim because adjusters have to separate wind damage from flood damage, and those are frequently different policies entirely.

Robeson County and the Lumberton area, just south of Fayetteville along the same river system, took some of the worst flooding from both storms, and commercial buildings there saw water damage patterns that Cumberland County property owners now recognize as a preview of what a slow-moving system can do even well inland from the coast.

Why Documentation Timing Matters More Than Anything Else

A roof claim lives or dies on what got recorded and when. We photograph damage before any tarping or emergency work changes what's visible, then photograph again after temporary repairs, so there's a clear before-and-after record instead of a gap an adjuster has to fill in with assumptions.

We take moisture readings at the deck and insulation, not only at the membrane surface, because water travels laterally under a membrane and shows up somewhere other than the visible damage point. That reading is part of the record we hand over, whatever the eventual outcome of the claim.

We do not promise a claim will be approved, and we don't inflate a scope of damage to chase a bigger number. Our job is an accurate, dated record and a defensible repair scope. The insurer's adjuster and the building owner's own coverage decide the rest.

We also keep a copy of every report we generate for the property owner's own file, not the version handed to an adjuster alone, because a claim can get reopened or appealed months after the original inspection, and having the original record in hand speeds that process up considerably.

  • Pre-repair photo documentation of all visible damage
  • Emergency tarp and dry-in to stop ongoing water intrusion
  • Moisture survey at deck and insulation layers
  • Written scope separating wind, water, and pre-existing conditions
  • Coordination with the property's own adjuster or public adjuster
  • Permanent repair or replacement once scope is finalized

Separating Storm Damage From What Was Already There

A lot of commercial roofs in this region were already at or past the end of a normal service life when Florence hit, and adjusters know that. Part of an honest scope is distinguishing wear that predates the storm from damage the storm caused, because conflating the two is the fastest way to get a claim denied outright.

We flag pre-existing ponding, prior patch work, and membrane wear separately in our documentation, in writing, rather than letting it get folded into the storm-damage narrative. That level of separation tends to hold up better under adjuster review than a scope that reads as a full-replacement wish list.

Emergency Response Without the Runaround

When a roof is actively leaking during or right after a storm, the priority is stopping water intrusion, not paperwork. We tarp and dry-in first, then document, then schedule the permanent scope, in that order, because a building full of water damage from a slow contractor response becomes its own separate loss.

We coordinate scheduling with property managers and facilities staff who are usually fielding storm damage across more than one building at once in the days after a regional event, so our crews show up on a schedule that's realistic instead of a promise nobody can keep during a fleet-wide storm response.

Questions About Storm and Insurance Claim Roofing

Will you guarantee my insurance claim gets approved?

No, and any contractor who tells you that is overstating what they control. What we provide is accurate documentation and a defensible repair scope. The approval decision belongs to the insurer.

How fast can you get a tarp on a leaking roof after a storm?

We prioritize active leaks over scheduled work during a regional storm event and move emergency dry-in ahead of the queue. Exact timing depends on how widespread the damage is across the area at that moment.

Can you tell the difference between storm damage and an old, worn roof?

Yes, and we document that difference in writing rather than blending it into one scope. That distinction is often what determines whether a claim gets approved or challenged.

Do you work with public adjusters as well as insurance company adjusters?

Yes. We provide the same factual documentation regardless of who's reviewing it, and we're available to walk a roof with either one.

What should a property owner do first after storm damage, before calling anyone?

Photograph what you can see safely from the ground or an interior vantage point, and call for emergency tarping if there's active water intrusion. Don't wait on a full inspection to stop a leak that's already inside the building.

Ready to review the roof scope?

Request a Roof Assessment